← Back to blog
Reflections

Why Being the Strong One Keeps Love Out

By Andy Petranek

Andy Petranek as a young Marine training at Camp Pendleton, in camouflage, a knit cap and military-issue glasses, holding a rifle on a dirt hillside.

Uh oh, I thought. A locker inspection. They’re going through all our stuff. They’re going to find it… the trumpet I’d hidden under everything else I’d brought.

It was the first day of Boys State, a five-day American Legion camp where tenth graders got to see democracy in action. A group of Marines played the dictators we’d spend the week overthrowing.

By then, I’d gotten very good at keeping parts of me hidden, at least from anyone who wasn’t a musician. And not just any parts… the ones I was best at and most proud of. For me, that was playing the trumpet.

I’d convinced myself that the things that made me stand out would keep me an outsider. Deep inside, part of me wanted to be seen for everything I was. But if being seen meant being different, the price was too high.

We’d been told to bring our instruments, and my mom made sure I didn’t “forget” mine. The minute I got to my locker, I buried it at the bottom. The last thing I wanted was to be pulled out and treated differently.

Now a Marine drill instructor was closing in on my locker. By the time he found the trumpet, they’d already picked the band, so I figured I was off the hook.

“What’s this?” he said. “So… you play the trumpet!? Are you any good?”

“Yes, sir.” I didn’t have it in me to lie about that.

Later, when I reported to his “office,” I was pretty sure I was in trouble.

“So what can you play?” he asked.

“What do you want to hear?” I asked.

“Oh, you’re cocky, huh?”

I wasn’t trying to be cocky. I was being honest. I could play just about anything.

He asked if I knew the song from that Budweiser commercial with the horses. I put the trumpet to my lips and played it, perfectly, the first time. He was blown away.

In that moment, his reaction felt like the acknowledgment I’d always been looking for from my own dad. Somebody was finally listening. The relief was so big that I wanted to cry.

And I couldn’t, because I was supposed to be tough. So I swallowed it.

I wanted so badly to be seen, and I didn’t even know it. And the moment someone finally saw me, I made sure nobody could see how much it meant to me.

He was so impressed, and loved that tune so much that he didn’t just make me join the band, he put me in charge of it. My arrangement of that song became the theme song for the whole week. Nobody there ever knew how close I’d come to crying in his office.

That became the way I operated.

Big feeling? Tuck it away. Proud moment? Pretend it means nothing. Tears during a movie… keep them hidden. Sad songs or “soft” pop… don’t let anyone notice. Armor up. And don’t ever, ever, ever let anyone see you cry.

For the next forty years, I was convinced the soft, emotional, creative, musical side of me had to stay hidden.

So I went the other direction. Somewhere deep down, I believed that if I did enough tough things, the teddy-bear side of me might just go away. And even if it didn’t, at least I could keep it buried at the bottom of that locker.

The first thing to go was the trumpet. I quit playing.

After that, if it looked hard, I did it. The Marine Corps. Multiple Eco-Challenges, a race people called the hardest on earth. 24- to 36-hour adventure and mountain bike races. Whitewater kayaking in the Sierras. Outrigger paddling off California and Molokai. Climbs up Mount Whitney and Mount Rainier. And in 2009, at forty-three, the CrossFit Games.

What I didn’t talk about was that softer side. I’d locked it up… and swallowed the key.

But it needed somewhere to go. And in 1996, in the middle of all that proving, it found its place. Its teacher. Its guide… Mona.

Mona, Andy’s longtime teacher and mentor, smiling at an evening event, with city lights through the windows behind her.

She’s hard to describe. Therapist, healer, mentor… none of them is quite right. She had no degrees and no certifications. But when she spoke, this incredible wisdom poured out of her.

Her energy? Pure love. Soft, compassionate, understanding and unconditionally accepting… and at the same time, surprisingly fierce and strong. She’s the closest thing to a living angel I’ve ever known.

I met her at something everyone called group. For the first year, I sat in the back with my journal, taking notes like a fly on the wall. Eventually I started seeing her one on one.

In one of our first sessions, she told me how badly I needed to cry. I thought, No way. A tough guy like me?

But at the very next session, I spent forty-five minutes on the floor, bawling my eyes out. I don’t even remember what it was about. What I remember is finding out how much I’d been holding in, probably since way before Boys State.

That was just the beginning. I saw her every week for years.

And I told almost no one.

I don’t remember ever deciding to keep it a secret. I just did. But looking back, I’m pretty sure I was afraid that if word got out, it would make me look weak, like someone who needed help (and shouldn’t) and couldn’t figure it out on his own (and should). And I was always competing, always trying to win. Showing that side of me would have felt way too much like losing.

So I kept Mona in her own box. The most meaningful part of my life was also the part I worked hardest to hide.

Hidden or not, Mona was a big part of why my wife, Julia, and I made it.

I knew early on that what Julia and I had was real. There was so much love between us, and a bond strong enough to build a marriage on, even through the hard years ahead.

But if our relationship was going to work, I’d have to learn to take the armor off. Mona helped me loosen it, but at home, it came flying back into place, over and over and over again. And when it did, I’d find a way to make it about Julia.

The partners we choose are often our best teachers. It’s just that in the hard times, we can’t see it. I sure couldn’t.

Eventually Julia started coming to see Mona with me… much to her chagrin at times. If I’m honest, part of me thought, Good. Finally, someone who can “fix” her.

Mona had other plans. Every time I swung the spotlight onto Julia, Mona turned it right back onto me. The only way through, she helped me see, was to take full responsibility.

Still, seeing it in Mona’s room was one thing. Living it at home was another. When Julia brought something up, I’d get defensive, or “teachy,” and it usually didn’t end well.

Over time, she started sharing a lot of those things with her friends instead. Neither of us wanted that. But every time I got defensive, I was teaching her that I wasn’t safe.

Over the years, I drifted away from Mona. Then, in 2011, she died suddenly in a car accident.

It felt like the rug had been pulled out from under me.

There were 350 people at her memorial. As I looked around that room, I realized every one of them felt about Mona the way I did. She had seen each of them. She had loved each of them, no conditions attached.

And it hit me: I’d had it backwards my whole life. I’d always believed holding back was what kept me safe.

Mona never held back her love. It was like a spring that never ran dry, always bubbling up and out of her. And the more she gave, the more it multiplied.

I’d been doing the opposite. I was afraid that if I gave my love away, it might run out. So I was stingy with it. I measured it out, kept score, and made sure I got some first.

All that holding back, the very thing I thought was keeping me safe, was what kept me locked up.

I remember thinking, God, what am I waiting for?

Something in me just got tired of holding back. I left the memorial, called the University of Santa Monica and enrolled in their master’s program in Spiritual Psychology. In my tough-guy days, it would have been the last thing I’d ever sign up for.

That day was the real start. But the walls came down slowly, in pieces.

Even at USM, I didn’t let many people see what it meant to me. I invited my staff at CrossFit LA, the gym I’d opened in 2004, to my graduation, and I still don’t think any of them knew.

I’ve been a work in progress ever since. There’s no such thing as a poor student or a slow learner, but a previous version of me would have called me both. The walls were thick, and I was stubborn. But I’ve stayed in the game, and I’ve never given up.

Nowhere have I felt the change more than at home, with Julia. And what’s made the biggest difference? Learning to see myself the way Mona always saw me… through compassionate, loving eyes.

For most of my life, I thought I could achieve my way to peace and love… money, success, accolades, winning. But that’s working from the outside in. No matter how hard I pushed, it never got me there.

What I’ve learned is that it works like a radio. I’m the receiver. If I want to pick up the station that’s broadcasting peace and love, I have to tune my dial to it. And the way I tune it is by creating it in me first. For years, the armor kept all that good stuff hidden behind walls, and I sat there turning the dial, wondering why nothing came through.

Creating it in me first is what started to fill my cup. As I began giving myself the love I’d always waited to get from someone else, I wasn’t waiting on anyone anymore. And with a fuller cup, I had a lot more to give. I got more patient and kinder. And I stopped needing Julia to change for things to feel better between us.

The change took years. I’ve done my best to see Julia’s life through her eyes instead of just mine, and some days I’m better at it than others. I’ve had to own my part instead of blaming her. I’ve had to let go of getting it right, teaching and one-upping. I’ve had to slow down and trust the process.

And Julia’s trust in me has turned 180 degrees. She talks to me now, really talks to me, because most of the time, she knows it’s safe.

I’m so grateful she hung in there with me, and for our greatest creation together, our son, Dashel.

Somewhere along the way, vulnerability became one of my superpowers. It sure didn’t start that way.

If any of this sounds familiar, you might be the steady one, the one everybody leans on, the one who always says “I’m good.” You might also get defensive faster than you’d like to admit.

Here’s a practice, if you’re up for it. For the next week, notice what station you’re tuned to.

Notice what you tuck away… the feeling you swallow during a movie, the song you turn down when someone walks in, the “I’m good” that comes out before you’ve even thought about it.

And notice what you push back with. The moment someone you love brings something up and you feel yourself bracing. The urge to explain, or correct them, or point out what they should be doing differently. That quiet certainty that this one’s on them.

That’s the armor, too. Part of it hides your soft side. The other part fights back and makes the other person the problem. Both parts block the signal.

Then, when you’re ready, pick one thing you want more of, like love, or peace, or connection, and create a little of it in yourself first. Give it before you get it.

It can start small. Let one person who feels safe see a little more of you. One honest answer to “How are you?”

Mona never hid the soft parts of herself. She broadcast love every day of her life, and 350 people tuned in and reflected it right back.

I think a lot about that kid at Boys State, swallowing his tears because he was supposed to be tough. He buried the best parts of himself at the bottom of a locker, sure they’d keep him on the outside.

The part I kept hidden turned out to be the part that lets the signal in. I’m still learning to trust that it’s safe to leave that locker open, and to let those softer parts of me be seen.

With love, Andy

P.S. This essay is one of five about the different ways we try to earn a place we already have. If you’re curious which one runs your life, I built a short quiz that’ll show you. It just takes a few minutes. Take the quiz

The Series:

Ready to talk about where you actually are today?

Curious which pattern is running yours? Find your pattern →