Why You Keep Trying to Prove You Belong
By Andy Petranek
I remember the day like it was yesterday. I was trying out for the seventh-grade basketball team. I had been doing my best to keep up, and I actually thought I was doing pretty well. Of course, there was this one thing. I had the world’s most awkward layup. The ball usually went in, but I knew I wasn’t doing it like the other boys, and I couldn’t figure out what I was doing wrong or how to fix it. No biggie… I was still getting the ball in the basket, I told myself.
And then came the first day of cuts. I was nervous, but not terribly. After all, I was keeping up, or so I thought.
The coach was merciful: instead of reading off the names of the kids who got cut, he read the names of the kids who were invited to come back the next day.
My name wasn’t on the list.
I was crushed. Embarrassed. It all happened so quickly, and so publicly. All I really wanted was to be on the court so that I could hang out with my friends. But I wasn’t built for basketball. I was the shortest, scrawniest kid at tryouts. My friends would all go on to be varsity starters.
Over the next few years, we went different directions, at least during the school day. They played basketball. I put everything into the trumpet. By junior year, I was a marching band geek, thoroughly uncool, and also one of the best high school trumpet players in the country. I sat first chair in both the All-State and All-Eastern bands, and my senior year I won one of only four spots for freshman trumpet players at the Eastman School of Music, one of the top conservatories in the country.
You’d think that would have been enough. But it was never really about the trumpet, or about basketball. It was about whether I belonged. In my friends’ eyes, or at least in the story I told myself about their eyes, I still didn’t measure up. So after school, I kept showing up to play their game.
Most days, a bunch of us met on one of the two driveway courts on my street. As long as we were just shooting around, it was fun. I loved hanging out with my friends. But every day, shooting around turned into picking sides and playing two-on-two or three-on-three. That’s when it got rough for me.
My friends loved it. Playing the game when you’re good at it and matched up against players of equal ability is great. But for me, every moment was a struggle to keep up… and to keep my chin up when their unspoken challenge was to find a new and creative way to “stuff” me. It was easy for them. I’d go up for a shot and one of them invariably would smack the ball right out of my hands. They never got tired of it. I didn’t seem to either.
But inside, it was tearing me up. I wanted so badly to be on equal ground with them. To be good at what they were good at. It was the way I measured my worth at the time… how well could I keep up with them on the basketball court? Sure, it was their game. Sure, it was one of the things I was worst at. But that didn’t matter. It was the only measure I’d accept for whether I belonged.
The funny (not so funny) thing was that I already did belong! We’d been friends for years. I was one of the guys… I’d already “made the team,” so to speak, and yet, I kept trying out.
So why did I keep putting myself through it? Nobody was forcing me. In fact, my friends probably don’t know to this day that any of that was going on inside of me. But it was.
And in a way, I didn’t have a choice. Somewhere very early on, long before that tryout, I’d made up a story to make sense of how I felt around other people: when it truly came down to it, I didn’t fit in. I didn’t belong.
I don’t remember deciding it. Kids never do. Maybe it started at home, with a dad who was always busy with his violin students, and a boy practicing his trumpet down the hall, hoping he’d come out and listen. However it got there, to me it felt like plain fact about who I was. And when something feels like fact, you don’t question it. You build your life around it.
And to that kid, the stakes felt enormous. I know how that sounds. Who’s terrified of a pickup game in a driveway? But the part of us that’s wired to belong takes being left out very seriously. For most of human history, getting pushed out of the group was genuinely dangerous, and some old part of us still reacts that way. So questioning the story never even occurred to me. Staying in felt like survival.
At the same time, I built a way to protect myself from that fear. I would do whatever it took to fit in, to prove I did belong. And fitting in meant fitting into what mattered to other people, much more than what mattered to me.
Those afternoons on the court fed both. They proved the story right: look at how I play basketball, of course I don’t fit in. And they gave me a place to prove I could fit in anyway, whatever it cost. The story was running the show, and I was at its mercy. To have any real choice, I would have needed to see what was happening. Trust me… I couldn’t see any of it.
That was more than forty years ago, and I’ve spent a lot of those years learning to see this pattern and work with it. I catch it much faster now, and I have a lot more compassion for the part of me that just wants to belong. But it still sneaks up on me.
The biggest time it caught me was in 2019, and boy, did it wallop me. The Whole Life Challenge, the online health program I’d spent a decade building, was supposed to be my proof that I belonged. More than 200,000 people had come through it, and I’d pictured it being worth millions and changing how people live. Then the growth stalled, and that future quietly disappeared. The business kept going, and it still helps a lot of people. But the version I’d been counting on was gone, and I fell apart.
It felt like the world smacking the ball out of my hands one last time, the final proof that I wasn’t enough and didn’t belong. It took me years to see that it hadn’t proven anything. The old story had just found its biggest piece of evidence yet.
These days it shows up in smaller ways, especially in enrollment, the process I use to bring on new clients.
A while back, I started talking with an executive who was referred to me by a client. He had a lot going on, at work and at home. We had multiple conversations. Before I ever offer someone the chance to become a client, I want it to be abundantly clear that we’ve identified a project worthy of their time, energy, money, and life.
We went through the process. Got to know each other. Identified the project. It was clear. I was clear. Everything lined up. I was committed. And I offered.
And he said no.
He was kind about it. He thanked me over and over again for the breakthroughs he’d already had from the work we’d done together. He also left the door open for later. It was simply a business decision. A no.
But that’s not how I took it. I took it personally, like a verdict on me. Dejected. Hurt. Inadequate. Afraid. I felt ashamed, like I should have known better than to want it more than he did.
In that moment, I was sixteen again, back on the driveway, the ball smacked out of my hands, sure I didn’t belong.
My mind tried everything to make it go away: the logic, my other successes, the clients I already had, the other people I was talking to. None of it helped.
This time, though, something was different. Somewhere in the middle of all those feelings, I recognized them. I knew this hurt. I’d been carrying it since I was a kid.
So I stopped trying to make the feelings go away. I let them be there and kept doing what I do most days: meditating, journaling, a cold plunge, a long walk. Those practices gave me room to do the part that actually mattered.
I turned toward that little guy inside, the one who was so sure he didn’t belong. I let him feel what he felt, without trying to fix it, and I brought as much compassion and love as I could to the places inside that hurt. I forgave myself for all the shoulds I’d been piling on, like “I shouldn’t have expected him to say yes,” and “I shouldn’t get upset like this, not after all these years of doing this work.” Then I told him what that kid on the driveway needed to hear all along. You’re going to be okay. I’m here with you. I’m never going to leave your side. I love you.
And somewhere in there, he found his footing. So did I.
If any of this sounds familiar, you probably have your own version of the driveway. Maybe it’s a boardroom, or the inbox you keep checking after you send a proposal. Somewhere along the way you decided what you had to be good at to belong, and odds are it was whatever mattered most to other people.
The next time a no, or a silence, hits harder than the moment calls for, notice what you’re feeling. Shame. Fear. Anxiety. That sinking sense of not being enough. Maybe anger, too, the kind that lands on the wrong person or the wrong thing. When the feeling is way bigger than what actually happened, that’s usually a sign something old just got stirred up.
From there, slow down in whatever way works for you, a walk or ten quiet minutes with a journal. Then write down the shoulds you’re piling on yourself. Read them back and ask whether you’d ever say them to a kid you loved. Whatever you wouldn’t say to them, you can stop saying to yourself.
And if you’re up for it, let one person who matters to you see what’s really going on. Say one true thing. Small is how it starts.
All that proof I kept collecting never proved a thing. I made the team a long time ago. So did you. You just might be the last one to find out.
With love, Andy
P.S. This essay is one of five about the different ways we try to earn a place we already have. If you’re curious which one runs your life, I built a short quiz that’ll show you. It just takes a few minutes.
Take the quiz
The Series:
- Why You Keep Trying to Prove You Belong: doing whatever it takes to fit in (this one)
- Why You Keep the People You Love at Arm’s Length: keeping one foot out the door of every group I’ve loved being part of
- Why Being the Strong One Keeps Love Out: the soft side of me I kept hidden for forty years
- Why Success Never Feels Like Enough: never being able to stop long enough to feel like you’ve made it
- Why You Keep Trying to Earn a Place You Already Have: what all four have in common
Ready to talk about where you actually are today?
Curious which pattern is running yours? Find your pattern →