← Back to blog
Reflections

Why You Keep Trying to Earn a Place You Already Have

By Andy Petranek

Andy Petranek speaking on a side stage at PaleoFX, with a PaleoFX banner beside him.
Speaking on a side stage at PaleoFX

Near the end of the movie The American President, Michael Douglas walks into the White House press room. His character, President Andrew Shepherd, has spent the whole film running for reelection, absorbing his opponent’s attacks and trying to protect his poll numbers. Now he stops playing defense. He gives the speech he’s been holding back, and he closes it with one line: “My name is Andrew Shepherd, and I am the president.”

He isn’t asking anymore. He’s telling them who he already is.

I think about that scene a lot, because for most of my life, I’ve been the guy still campaigning.

I’ve always wanted to be seen the way my teachers and mentors were seen. Some of my friends, too.

Two of those friends were Robb Wolf and Mark Sisson.

Robb and I were there at the start of CrossFit, when it was little more than a handful of gyms and a training system built on Greg Glassman’s answer to one question: What is fitness? Robb opened one of the very first of those gyms. I opened CrossFit LA, the ninth, in 2004. We were building communities from scratch, and nothing else in fitness looked like what we were doing. Mark came from outside CrossFit. He’d built his business around his blog, Mark’s Daily Apple, and his book, The Primal Blueprint. He lived just up the coast, we had a lot of friends in common, and over the years we got to know each other well.

Over the next several years, the two of them became leaders of the paleo movement. They wrote the books and built the companies, and when that world got together at conferences like PaleoFX, they were the people everyone came to hear.

I was building, too. The Whole Life Challenge, which I’d co-founded, was helping thousands of people change how they ate, moved and lived. I believed in that work. When I went to those conferences, I was as fired up to be there as anyone in the room.

Underneath the mission, though, I wanted people to look at me the way they looked at Robb and Mark. I’d have loved to hear one of them say, “Hey kid. Welcome to the club. You’re one of us.” That would have mattered to me. It really would have.

But even that wouldn’t have been enough. I wanted the whole room to see me that way.

The irony is that thousands of people already did. They’d come through the Whole Life Challenge, and they looked at me exactly that way. PaleoFX even asked me to speak. It was a side stage and a small crowd, but I was up there. I didn’t let any of it count. I was too busy scanning the room for the people who didn’t, and judging myself by them. I’ve been doing some version of that my whole life.

For the last couple of months, I’ve been writing about the different ways I’ve tried to earn my place.

There was the seventh grader who got cut from the basketball team and spent hours in the driveway getting good at the one thing everyone else cared about, so he could prove he belonged. There was the guy who loved every group he was ever part of, and still kept one foot out the door, so nobody could ever push him out. There was the kid who buried his trumpet at the bottom of a locker and spent the next forty years making sure nobody saw the soft parts of him.

And there’s the one I’ve lived inside the longest. The Marines. The Eco-Challenges. CrossFit LA. The Whole Life Challenge. If I built enough and won enough, I’d finally have earned my place. And every time I got there, the place moved.

Four different stories. And underneath all of them, the same thing.

We all pay with something. Some people pay with wins and achievements. Some pay by saying yes when they mean no, or by making sure everyone else is okay before they ever check on themselves. Some pay by never letting anyone see them struggle. Others pay by keeping everyone at a safe distance, close enough to feel connected and far enough to never get hurt.

What we pay with looks different from person to person. But what we’re trying to buy is the same. We want to know we belong, and that we’re loved just as we are.

The difference between me and the president in that movie is who I’ve been campaigning to.

Plenty of people in my life already see me the way I want to be seen. My wife, Julia, most of all. She sees someone who has already arrived, with nothing left to prove and nothing left to earn. And she watches me keep trying to prove it anyway.

We’re looking at the same guy and seeing two completely different people. I don’t think there’s one right way to see yourself. But if I get to pick, I’d much rather see what she sees. The trouble is, I’ve spent my whole life picking my own version without noticing I was picking at all. It’s a habit. Autopilot.

The voter I’ve been campaigning to all these years is me.

Every time I feel like I have to prove that I belong, or prove that I’m a keeper, I’m quietly telling myself that I’m not. Think about it. Who needs to prove they belong?

Only someone who doesn’t.

The proving is what creates the lack.

I know how that sounds. I used to have it the other way around. I thought the feeling came first and the proving fixed it. Feel the gap, close the gap. But every time I performed my way into a room, some part of me filed it away as more evidence that I wouldn’t have been let in without the performance. So all that paying kept the old story alive.

And the proving always comes with a twin. If I’m always proving, I’m also always hiding, because anything that doesn’t fit the performance has to go somewhere. The trumpet at the bottom of the locker. The tears I swallowed. The foot I kept by the door.

If I’m always proving and always hiding, nobody ever gets to see the real me. They only see the version of me that’s trying out. So even when they say yes, it doesn’t really land, because some part of me knows they said yes to the performance.

Which means that even if Robb or Mark had said those words, and even if a whole room had looked at me the way I wanted, I’m pretty sure it still wouldn’t have been enough. They’d all have been looking at the guy who was trying out. And the only vote that ever counted was mine.

The funny (not so funny) thing is that the proof I was looking for has been sitting right next to me for years.

Julia chose me a long time ago, and it had nothing to do with anything I’d produced or won. She keeps choosing me. And I’ve had a hard time letting that count, because I didn’t earn it.

So I’ve been living every day with proof that I’m already on the team, and I’ve still been holding tryouts. And every tryout tells me, one more time, that I haven’t made it yet.

I’d bet you have some version of this, too. Someone who loves you who has never once asked you to perform for it. A friend who was glad to see you on a day you had nothing to show for yourself. A kid who doesn’t care what your title is. And chances are you’ve found a way to discount it, because it came too easy.

If you recognized yourself in any of this, here’s a practice, if you’re up for it.

For the next week, try to catch yourself working to earn your place. You’ll know it by the feeling. The extra push to impress someone, so they’ll think more of you. The yes that comes out before you’ve checked whether you mean it, so nobody’s disappointed in you. The “I’m good” when you’re not, so nobody sees you struggle. The way you go a little quiet, or suddenly get busy, when someone starts to get a little too close, so if it ever ends, you’re the one who walked away.

When you catch it, ask yourself two questions. What am I hoping this gets me? And is there any chance I already have it?

Most of the time, the answer to the first one is some version of the same thing. To belong. To be loved as you are.

Then, once this week, pick one of those and do the opposite. Skip the extra push and let something be good enough. Say no when you mean no. Give the real answer the next time someone asks how you’re doing. Or when someone gets a little too close, stay put and let them in.

It’ll probably feel strange. Maybe even a little risky, like you’re about to get found out. That’s the old story talking. Notice what actually happens. My guess is that nobody leaves.

I still catch myself holding tryouts. Less than I used to, and I’m a lot quicker to notice. But the team picked me a long time ago. I’m still learning to stop trying out.

With love, Andy

P.S. This essay wraps up a series about the different ways we try to earn a place we already have. If you’re curious which one runs your life, I built a short quiz that’ll show you. It just takes a few minutes. Take the quiz

The Series:

Ready to talk about where you actually are today?

Curious which pattern is running yours? Find your pattern →